Best Places to Stay in Put-in-Bay:
Here’s our manually curated guide to the best luxury, boutique, and coolest hotels in Put-in-Bay . Bon voyage!
Hannah, Travel Blogger
Updated Aug 2, 2022
Put-in-Bay Resort & Conference Center
Rated 8.8 in 298 reviews. 60 rooms.““We really enjoyed our stay at Tago Tulum and were very impressed with both the location and the spacious, and modern rooms. The beach was cleaned every morning so we had no issues with algae and the staff was always attentive and ready to assist.””. — Guest review
For a blend of luxury and convenience, the Put-in-Bay Resort & Conference Center offers spacious rooms, a large outdoor pool with a swim-up bar, and a complimentary breakfast. Guests can enjoy the resort’s modern amenities, including a fitness center, hot tub, and on-site restaurant. Its central location makes it easy to explore the island’s attractions, shops, and nightlife.
The Islander Inn
Rated 8.8 in 298 reviews. 60 rooms.““We really enjoyed our stay at Tago Tulum and were very impressed with both the location and the spacious, and modern rooms. The beach was cleaned every morning so we had no issues with algae and the staff was always attentive and ready to assist.””. — Guest review
The Islander Inn is another top choice for luxury accommodations on Put-in-Bay. This resort features multiple outdoor pools, a tiki bar, and comfortable rooms with modern amenities. The resort’s lively atmosphere and convenient location near the downtown area make it a great option for those looking to enjoy the island’s vibrant nightlife and entertainment options.
The Anchor Inn
Boutique Hotel
Rated 8.8 in 298 reviews. 60 rooms.
““We really enjoyed our stay at Tago Tulum and were very impressed with both the location and the spacious, and modern rooms. The beach was cleaned every morning so we had no issues with algae and the staff was always attentive and ready to assist.””. — Guest review
The Anchor Inn Boutique Hotel offers a cozy and intimate stay with its beautifully decorated rooms and modern amenities. Each room features a private bath, comfortable furnishings, and unique decor. Guests can enjoy a continental breakfast each morning and relax in the lovely garden or on the porch. The inn’s central location allows easy access to local attractions, shops, and dining options.
Commodore Resort
Rated 8.8 in 298 reviews. 60 rooms.““We really enjoyed our stay at Tago Tulum and were very impressed with both the location and the spacious, and modern rooms. The beach was cleaned every morning so we had no issues with algae and the staff was always attentive and ready to assist.””. — Guest review
Located in the heart of downtown Put-in-Bay, the Commodore Resort offers comfortable accommodations with a lively atmosphere. The resort features an outdoor pool, a swim-up bar, and an on-site nightclub. Guests can enjoy the convenience of being close to the island’s main attractions, restaurants, and bars. The Commodore Resort is perfect for those looking to be in the center of the action.
Harbour View Suites
Rated 8.8 in 298 reviews. 60 rooms.““We really enjoyed our stay at Tago Tulum and were very impressed with both the location and the spacious, and modern rooms. The beach was cleaned every morning so we had no issues with algae and the staff was always attentive and ready to assist.””. — Guest review
For a quieter and more relaxing stay, Harbour View Suites offers charming accommodations with stunning views of Lake Erie. Each suite is spacious and well-appointed, providing a comfortable and serene retreat. Guests can enjoy the peaceful surroundings, private balconies, and easy access to the island’s attractions. Harbour View Suites is an excellent choice for couples and families seeking a tranquil getaway.
Harbour View Suites
Rated 8.8 in 298 reviews. 60 rooms.““We really enjoyed our stay at Tago Tulum and were very impressed with both the location and the spacious, and modern rooms. The beach was cleaned every morning so we had no issues with algae and the staff was always attentive and ready to assist.””. — Guest review
For a quieter and more relaxing stay, Harbour View Suites offers charming accommodations with stunning views of Lake Erie. Each suite is spacious and well-appointed, providing a comfortable and serene retreat. Guests can enjoy the peaceful surroundings, private balconies, and easy access to the island’s attractions. Harbour View Suites is an excellent choice for couples and families seeking a tranquil getaway.
Bird’s Nest Resort
Rated 8.8 in 298 reviews. 60 rooms.““We really enjoyed our stay at Tago Tulum and were very impressed with both the location and the spacious, and modern rooms. The beach was cleaned every morning so we had no issues with algae and the staff was always attentive and ready to assist.””. — Guest review
For a home-away-from-home experience, Bird’s Nest Resort offers a variety of charming cottages and suites with all the comforts of home. Each unit is fully equipped with modern amenities, including kitchens, living areas, and outdoor spaces. Guests can enjoy the resort’s outdoor pool, picnic areas, and beautiful grounds. The friendly atmosphere and convenient location make Bird’s Nest Resort a popular choice among families and groups.
Put-in-Bay Condos
Rated 8.8 in 298 reviews. 60 rooms.““We really enjoyed our stay at Tago Tulum and were very impressed with both the location and the spacious, and modern rooms. The beach was cleaned every morning so we had no issues with algae and the staff was always attentive and ready to assist.””. — Guest review
Put-in-Bay Condos provide spacious and comfortable accommodations with stunning views of Lake Erie. Each condo features a fully equipped kitchen, private balcony, and modern amenities. Guests can enjoy the outdoor pool, barbecue facilities, and easy access to the island’s attractions. The condos are ideal for families and groups looking for a relaxing and convenient stay
Bay Lodging Resort
Rated 8.8 in 298 reviews. 60 rooms.““We really enjoyed our stay at Tago Tulum and were very impressed with both the location and the spacious, and modern rooms. The beach was cleaned every morning so we had no issues with algae and the staff was always attentive and ready to assist.””. — Guest review
For those seeking affordable accommodations, Bay Lodging Resort offers clean and comfortable rooms at a great value. The resort features an indoor-outdoor pool, a complimentary continental breakfast, and a convenient location near downtown Put-in-Bay. It’s an excellent choice for budget-conscious travelers looking to explore the island without breaking the bank.
Ahoy Inn Guesthouse
Rated 8.8 in 298 reviews. 60 rooms.““We really enjoyed our stay at Tago Tulum and were very impressed with both the location and the spacious, and modern rooms. The beach was cleaned every morning so we had no issues with algae and the staff was always attentive and ready to assist.””. — Guest review
For a romantic escape, Ahoy Inn Guesthouse offers beautifully decorated rooms with a touch of nautical charm. Each room features a private bath, comfortable furnishings, and unique decor. Guests can enjoy a complimentary continental breakfast, relax in the garden, and explore the nearby attractions. The inn’s intimate ambiance and personalized service make it a perfect choice for couples.
Nothing to your taste?
There are many more great places to stay available on Booking.com. Please let me know if you find something I should add to the list.
Lübeck
Hamburg
Prague
Bremen
Malmö
Copenhagen